My Coach Is a Robot. This Is Slightly Awkward.

I spend quite a lot of my working life talking about relationships.
Human connection. Being understood. Sitting with another person when things are uncomfortable. The things that happen between two people that can’t necessarily be explained neatly or fixed with the right words.

I also talk to a robot quite a lot. There. I’ve said it. I use AI.
Personally, I use it a bit like a coach. Somewhere to chuck the contents of my brain when there are too many things going on in it at once. Sometimes I want another perspective. Sometimes I already know what I think and apparently need to argue with something for twenty minutes before accepting it.
Professionally, I use it as a work aid. I might use it to help organise an idea, think about some theory, challenge my thinking, or turn the seventeen thoughts currently competing for attention in my head into something vaguely coherent.
And sometimes it gets things spectacularly wrong, and I think that’s quite important. Because I’ve noticed something about the way we talk about AI. We seem to want it to be either brilliant or terrifying:
It’s going to revolutionise everything.
It’s going to take everyone’s jobs.
It’s dangerous.
It’s the future.
It’s cheating.
It’s basically just a fancy autocomplete.
I’m not sure I sit comfortably in any of those camps. I think it’s useful -actually, I think it’s really useful, and I think we need to be careful with it. Two things can be true at the same time.
I don’t want AI to agree with me
One of the things I’ve found unexpectedly useful is having something available when I want to think -and I do mean think, rather than simply ask it for an answer. There’s a difference. If I take something to AI and say, essentially, “Tell me I’m right”, I’m fairly sure I could construct the conversation in a way that gets me there. Humans are pretty good at doing that without AI, to be fair.

What I find much more useful is asking it to challenge me:
What haven’t I considered?
Am I being fair here?
Is there another way of understanding this?
Am I overthinking it?
Am I avoiding something?
Occasionally the response makes me think, Oh. Bugger. And those are usually the useful ones. Other times I read what it has produced and think, No. You’ve completely misunderstood me - and strangely, that can be useful too. Having to explain why I disagree makes me work out what I actually think.
That’s probably the biggest distinction I’ve noticed in how I use AI now. I don’t particularly want it to do my thinking for me. I want something I can think alongside.
There are areas of my professional life where I’m much more cautious. I’m a counsellor, and confidentiality and ethical responsibility are a huge part of what I do, so AI isn’t something I use without thinking about what I’m putting into it or what I’m asking it to do. For me, it’s much more useful around the edges of running a practice. Writing, admin, organising my slightly chaotic thoughts and researching ideas when I’ve been staring at a blank screen for far too long.
And I think that’s probably where my line sits. I’m quite happy for AI to make parts of my working life easier. I’m considerably less comfortable with the idea of handing over the bits that require me to actually be the counsellor. Where that line should sit across the profession more generally, though, is becoming a much bigger question. And with the new BACP Ethical Framework, it’s one we’re going to have to think about properly.
Then AI started appearing in my therapy room
Not literally. That would be a very different article! But increasingly, AI is part of what people bring to therapy and the more I think about AI, the more I realise how many places it’s quietly appearing.
AI is becoming involved in how we work, how we communicate, how we search for information, how we create things and increasingly how decisions about us are made. I think there are some genuinely brilliant possibilities in that. There are also bits that make me wonder what we might lose if efficiency becomes more important than human contact.
I don’t have a particularly neat answer to that yet, which is probably why I keep thinking about it.
And meanwhile, my own profession is having to work this out

“Counselling isn’t somehow sitting outside all of this, AI is here too.Our ethical frameworks are having to catch up with technology that is moving ridiculously quickly. Counselling isn’t somehow sitting outside all of this, AI is here too.”
Our ethical frameworks are having to catch up with technology that is moving ridiculously quickly. Therapists are having conversations about confidentiality, data, competence, transparency and what responsible use actually looks like. And then there’s the enormous elephant sitting quietly in the corner of the therapy room: Could AI eventually replace therapists?
I have thoughts - quite a lot of them, unsurprisingly. And perhaps slightly inconveniently for me, I don’t think the answer is as simple as of course it can’t.
I’ve had genuinely useful conversations with AI. I’ve been challenged by it, I’ve had it spot something I hadn’t considered and I’ve used it when I’ve been overwhelmed, cross, confused or simply needed somewhere to put my thoughts. So I’m not going to spend this month pretending AI is incapable of being psychologically useful simply because I’m a counsellor and that would make the future of my profession feel more comfortable.
But I also know what happens in a therapy room. I know what it feels like when somebody tells another human being something they’ve carried with shame for years and waits to see what happens. I know the significance of silence, of misunderstanding someone, of repairing it. Of noticing what’s happening in me while I’m sitting opposite somebody and wondering whether that might tell us something about what’s happening between us - or - of two actual human beings trying to understand something together without either of them knowing exactly where they’re going.
I don’t know what AI means for all of that yet and I’m not sure anybody does. And perhaps that’s why I want to spend a month writing about it rather than rushing to decide whether I’m Team AI or Team Please Make It Go Away. I use AI, my clients are being affected by AI and my profession is having to make ethical decisions about AI. And yes, somewhere in the background there is the slightly uncomfortable question of whether the technology I currently use to help me do my job could one day try to do my job - which feels worth being curious about.
Even if my coach is a robot.
Stay curious.
About the Author
I’m Sarah, a counsellor based in Canterbury, UK. I work remotely and face-to-face with adults experiencing anxiety, relationship difficulties, low self-esteem, life transitions, and the challenges that come with being human.
Alongside my counselling work, I write about therapy, relationships, personal growth, and the gap between psychological advice and the realities of everyday life.
You can find out more about my counselling practice at:
If you enjoyed this article, you'll find my latest writing on The Village Counsellor on Substack. I publish new blogs there first, along with additional thoughts and deeper explorations of each month's theme.
A Note About This Publication
The articles and reflections shared here are intended for educational, informational, and leisure purposes only. They are not a substitute for therapy, counselling, medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment.
Reading about psychological ideas can sometimes offer insight, but it is not the same as having a therapeutic relationship with a qualified professional. If you are struggling with your mental health or need personal support, please seek appropriate professional help.


